Bishop William F. Medley greets a woman participating in the Feb. 17, 2024 Rite of Election and Call to Continuing Conversion held at St. Stephen Cathedral in Owensboro. RILEY GREIF | WKC

BY DCN. JAY W. VANHOOSIER, OFFICE OF FAITH FORMATION

The Catholic scrutinies, an integral part of the initiation process for catechumens (those seeking Baptism, Confirmation, and Eucharist), serve as a profound call to self-evaluation and transformation within the Catholic faith. Rooted in the belief that true conversion involves a deep examination of one’s life, the scrutinies invite individuals to reflect on their actions, choices, and spiritual journey. In this article, I would like to explore how the scrutinies compel all, both catechumens and the broader Catholic community, to assess their lives and embrace a path of renewal and growth.

The meaning and purpose of the scrutinies: The scrutinies are a series of rites within the OCIA (Order of Christian Initiation of Adults) that take place during the Lenten season. They are specifically designed to assist catechumens in their spiritual journey. The word “scrutiny” itself implies a careful examination or investigation, and in the context of the Catholic faith, it signifies a soul-searching process.

A call to self-examination: At the heart of the scrutinies is the call to self-examination. Catechumens are encouraged to scrutinize their lives, acknowledging their weakness and sins, and seeking God’s mercy. This process mirrors the broader invitation for all believers to engage in regular self-reflection. The scrutinies remind the faithful that spiritual growth requires a humble recognition of our shortcomings and a sincere desire for transformation.

The themes of light and darkness: The scrutinies are marked by a symbolic play of light and darkness. The imagery emphasizes the contrast between sin and the light of Christ. Through prayers, scripture readings, and rituals, the scrutinies challenge individuals to confront the darkness within themselves and, by God’s grace, move towards the light of redemption. This metaphorical journey is not exclusive to catechumens but resonates with every believer striving for a deeper relationship with God.

Community participation and support: While the scrutinies are a personal and introspective experience, they are not undertaken in isolation. The Catholic community plays a crucial role in supporting individuals through this transformative process. The congregation, by witnessing and participating in the scrutinies, reaffirms its commitment to accompanying each member on their spiritual journey. This communal aspect underscores the universality of the call to self-evaluation within the broader Catholic context.

Integration into everyday life: The lessons learned during the scrutinies extend beyond the ritualistic context. The call to evaluate one’s life becomes a continuous practice, integrated into everyday living. The Catholic faith encourages believers to carry the spirit of the scrutinies into their daily actions, fostering a conscious effort to align their lives with the teachings of Christ.

In essence, the Catholic scrutinies transcend their immediate purpose of preparing catechumens for sacramental initiation. They emerge as a powerful and universal call for all members of the faith to evaluate their lives, confront their weaknesses, and embrace a transformative journey toward God. Through self-examination, the interplay of light and darkness, community support, and the integration into daily life, the scrutinies beckon believers to embark on a lifelong pursuit of spiritual growth and renewal.

Dcn. Jay W. VanHoosier is the Director of Faith Formation for the Diocese of Owensboro. For more information visit owensborodiocese.org/faith-formation, email [email protected] or call (270) 852-8324.

Originally printed in the March 2025 issue of The Western Kentucky Catholic.